4 Historic Hotels & Inns in the Petoskey Area

‘Tis the time of year when all of us living in or visiting Northern Michigan have an innate desire to be contentedly cozy. Yes, our region—in particular the Petoskey Area—adores outdoor winter activities of all kinds, from skiing and sledding to snowshoeing and skating; however, even the most adventurous want a warm place to call home base at the end of each snow-filled day.

Part of our area’s charming character is its deep history, which seems to come alive this time of year—as if the walls, paintings, woodwork, and impressive vistas surrounding us want to share in the collective cheer and reminisce about what has occurred and look forward to the experiences to come.

When compared to the rest of the world, our northern corner near the tip of the mitten is relatively young without centuries of history to boast about. And yet, the Petoskey Area is the proud home of four historic hotels and inns that possess eclectic auras and fascinating histories all their own. 

Looking for a quaint place to rest your head in Northern Michigan? Why not consider booking with one of these storied establishments for your stay?

 

The Colonial Inn

In Harbor Springs, just around the Little Traverse Bay from Petoskey and part of the historic neighborhood and community of Wequetonsing, is the Colonial Inn, which has welcomed guests for more than 130 years.

One of only five Michigan properties recognized by Historic Hotels of America, the official program of the National Trust for Historic Preservation, the Colonial Inn is known as one of the finest historic inns to have faithfully maintained its authenticity, sense of place, and architectural integrity in the U.S.

Established in 1894, shortly after the Civil War concluded, the Colonial Inn was named for its original proprietor, Colonel Eaton of the Michigan Wolverines Cavalry Division, who was rumored to have been involved in the capture of Confederate President Jefferson Davis. After the passing of both Colonel Eaton and his widow, the inn was purchased by a former German World War I colonel in the 1920s. As you can see, the inn’s name was well-chosen, evidenced by its first two owners.

Subsequent proprietors included John R. Davis, Vice President of Ford Motor Company, and Fred Renker, a prominent Harbor Springs figure, as co-owners, followed by Ray Brown, who was succeeded by his son, Tim. Each of the modern-era owners had a hand in modernizing the Colonial Inn while ensuring its historical essence remained intact. 

Today, this historic inn features 42 restored rooms, in-room fireplaces, sprawling grounds that abut Lake Michigan—which include a private dock for catching sunsets or getting onto the water—and modern amenities such as an outdoor pool, jacuzzi, gym, and the newly introduced and aptly named “1894” cocktail bar.

Historically, the Colonial Inn has been a seasonal establishment, but beginning in the spring of 2026, the inn is shifting to year-round operations. So, no matter the time of year, you’re a quick drive or short walk from downtown Harbor Springs and its quaint shopping district, fun bar and restaurant scene, and the ever-bustling marina when you stay at the Colonial Inn! Plus, you’re not far from enjoying a game of golf at The Highlands, either!

The Terrace Inn

Back around the bay, heading south, you’ll find the beautiful Bay View Association, a multi-generational, seasonal resident community that aims to enrich the minds, bodies, and souls of its residents and visitors. 

Nestled within the winding streets of this National Historic Landmark and colorful Victorian association is the Terrace Inn & 1911 Restaurant, which proudly serves guests year-round. The Terrace Inn, built by Indiana banker William DeVol between 1910 and 1911, has changed hands several times in the past century, but is currently operated by Harbor Springs native Mary Beth Bennett and her husband, Matt.

The Bennetts, along with all who have come before them, have added their own touches, improvements, and changes to the historic inn while staying true to the establishment’s character. This inn includes 38 guest rooms—cozy cottage rooms and spacious suites—casual fine-dining at 1911 Restaurant, top-notch amenities, and easy access to downtown Petoskey and the Lake Michigan waterfront.

Now, it’s worth noting that the Terrace Inn does indeed have a haunted history, as customers and employees have seen, heard, and felt spectral presences over the years. But don’t let that deter you from booking your reservation! 

The Terrace Inn is a gorgeous setting in which to relax and take in the scenery, especially during the summer. The inn is a regular wedding venue and also a great vantage point for observing the colorful community, from its bedecked front porches and vibrant gardens to the countless events occurring in the various Bay View halls and auditoriums.

The Terrace Inn welcomes you to experience its quaint charm and create memories that will remain with you for years to come.

 

The Bay View Inn

Also part of the Bay View Association is the Bay View Inn, another delightful place to stay, which is actually a well-preserved and beautifully restored Victorian mansion on Lake Michigan.

Built in the late 19th century—more than 130 years ago—the Bay View Inn is a testament to the enduring appeal of a lakeside retreat and peaceful relaxation. Each of the inn’s rooms and suites offers a unique and distinct experience—no two are the same!—making your stay unlike anyone else’s. 

With pristine grounds and views of the Little Traverse Bay, guests can spend their time in the indoor and outdoor common areas, enjoy delicious meals at the in-house restaurant, the Roselawn Dining Room, and engage in a variety of activities thanks to the inn’s partnership with the Bay View Association. This historic and unmistakable retreat offers guests a step back in time, combined with luxury amenities.

For more than 60 years, the Bay View Inn was owned and operated by Janice and Stafford Smith and their family, who prided themselves on creating a space to pause and unwind from the hectic pace of modern life. Carrying on the hospitality tradition are new owners Jon and Lauren Cotton, Michigan hoteliers who have embraced the Smiths’ regional legacy and appreciation for maintaining the inn’s historic importance and integrity.

Located at a pivotal point in Petoskey, the Bay View Inn enables guests to easily head north to explore towns such as Harbor Springs and Alanson or travel south to visit Bay Harbor, Boyne City, or Boyne Falls. Those who enjoy biking or walking can easily traverse into downtown Petoskey for shopping, dining, and more via the Little Traverse Wheelway!

 

The Perry Hotel

Also owned by Jon and Lauren Cotton is the iconic and easily recognizable landmark of downtown Petoskey—The Perry Hotel, which is also listed on the National Register of Historic Sites. 

Overlooking the Little Traverse Bay with immediate access to the shopping and dining district, this hotel is the only one in downtown Petoskey, making it a one-of-a-kind in more than one way.

The Perry Hotel, which was initially geared toward wealthy businessmen traveling for work, opened in 1899, not long after the City of Petoskey was incorporated. In its 120+ year history of providing excellent service and accommodations, the Perry Hotel has become a place for everyone to enjoy.

Over the years, the Perry Hotel has undergone many changes, updates, and modernizations, yet thanks to its long line of proprietors, it has managed to preserve its grandeur and sophistication. 

Oddly enough, there was a time, early on in the hotel’s existence, that it was almost converted into a hospital by its owners, Drs. John and George Reycraft. However, the City of Petoskey stepped in and persuaded the powers that be to keep the Perry Hotel as it was—a place of refined relaxation and cultural society.

Of the 21 hotels that called Petoskey home in 1900, the Perry Hotel is the only remaining operational establishment—a testament to its value, the hard work of its owners, and historical relevance to the Petoskey Area.

From the breathtaking views out of the Rose Room’s dining area and cozy subterranean pub-vibe of the on-site Noggin Room to the unique rooms and suites, the Perry Hotel has it all—comfort, fun, good food, and an unparalleled view of the Petoskey Area.

Each of these hotels and inns would be lucky to count you as a guest in its fabled history spanning more than a century—and if luck holds, these historic establishments will be around for another century or more!

About the Author: Alex Dailey is a long-time Northern Michigan resident who happily calls Petoskey home. When she isn’t at her computer writing and editing, you can find her taste-testing craft cocktails, patronizing downtown shops (especially bookstores), and participating in as many local literary events as possible. She looks forward to sharing her Petoskey Area favorites with you!